Sunday, October 13, 2019

Correcting Mistakes

In recent decades there has been an active effort worldwide to remove elevated highways. Many such highways, constructed in the middle of the 20th century to speed traffic, are now seen as obstacles to vibrant urban development.

Tom McCall Park in Portland, Oregon
From Korea to the United Statesa, there has been a new awareness of unintended consequences related to these expensive and massive highway structures designed to overcome traffic congestion. They  were found to be a medicine more devastating than the congestion disease. Progress in correcting this mistake has been slow but steady since Portland, Oregon removed its riverside freeway and replaced it with a park in 1972.

Korea


In Seoul, Korea, a former river was placed underground when an elevated highway was completed in 1976.  Restoration starting in 1973 returned the river to a more natural state and removed most of the highway lanes. Mayor Lee of Seoul who was responsible for the elevated highway removal and the creation of a riverside park upon the former highway site, was elected Korea's president in December 2007.


Cheonggyecheon River restoration project

 

Seattle


Future Seattle waterfront envisioned by 2023
Progress on the most recent elevated highway removal is occurring in Seattle, WA with the replacement of the Alaska Way Viaduct.

In the Fall of 2011, Seattle's Alaskan Way Viaduct began to crumble. City planners and downtown businesses hoped the removal of the elevated structure would be the catalyst for a whole new waterfront with a broad pedestrian way and a seaside promenade. In November 2012 voters approved by 77 percent a $290 million bond measure to pay for replacement of the most eroded and threatened section of the sea wall — a linchpin of the waterfront renewal package. 

After numerous interruptions, a Viaduct replacement tunnel constructed using the Big Bertha tunneling machine was completed.  Traffic is now rolling through the new underground way. 

Final demolition of the former Alaska Viaduct is now underway. Progress on one segment can be viewed on this video of demolition in May 2019. 

The two images envision scenes on the future waterfront after implementation of the plan. Waterfront construction is anticipated to be completed in summer 2023. Seattle Magazine provided an overview early in 2019 of the future expected Bold New Waterfront experience.

San Francisco


The San Francisco waterfront was blocked off after the Embarcadero Freeway was constructed in the late 1950s. There was a dreary darkness associated with the spaces beneath and the buildings under the shadow of this massive structure. If it wasn't for the San Francisco citizen revolt that followed its construction, the freeway would have eventually walled off the waterfront as far as the Golden Gate. As it was, it extended more than half a kilometer north of the Ferry Building before it turned inland upon its final off ramps.

Art Agnos, Former San Francisco Mayor
The 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake damaged the structure. At first the State of California planned to retrofit and retain the two-decker freeway. Then Mayor Art Agnos proposed demolishing the freeway in favor of a boulevard with a large plaza in front of the Ferry Building.

Opposition to demolishing the freeway came from Chinatown and the city's downtown businesses. Agnos continued to negotiate with federal and state officials to win enough funding to make the demolition practical. The opposition quieted. Demolition began in 1991.

The city and its downtown and Chinatown businesses survived quite nicely with the renovated Embarcadero. In the image below we see the Embarcadero no longer shadowed by the elevated behemoth. The Ferry Building insert shows how it was previously walled off by the elevated, double-deck highway.

The view looks north along the Embarcadero toward the Ferry Building. The inset is an aerial view of the Ferry Building when the Embarcadero Freeway still existed. H Graem © 2007

June 16, 2006, the Port of San Francisco unveiled a monument to Mayor Agnos honoring his vision and courage, noting "This pedestrian pier commemorates the achievement of Mayor Agnos in leaving our city better and stronger than he found it."






No comments:

Post a Comment